Return to Guidelines

REPRINT
Brown, Bob: Who Will Publish My Short Story? Writers’ Journal; Nov/Dec 2007, Page 23.

Who Will Publish My Short Story?

Find The Perfect Magazine For Your Story 

Bob Brown

Dueling Partners was destined to be my best ever Short Story, or so I thought. I knew my story was long (13,381 words), but it is so good, how could any literary magazine turn it down? Nearly all of them, I found out. It would be an easy call for the magazine editor; one glance at my word count and my beautiful manuscript would be tossed into the recycle bin without him even reading the title.

Thus began my quest to find magazines that wanted long stories. I eventually found several, but only after banging away on my computer for several days. Intensive searching of the Internet soon overwhelmed my tiny brain cells and they mired up knee-deep in guidelines information. To eliminate confusion, I constructed a chart to organize my list of magazines. Since most of my stories are much shorter than Dueling Partners, I also listed magazines that accepted stories of many different lengths. My list of over 300 magazines grew faster than Jack’s Beanstalk. It occurred to me that many Short Story authors would find my chart as useful as I have, so I gave the chart the title of Submissions Guidelines and put it on my Web site. See:

www.inventwrite.com/Guidelines.htm

Using the chart is simple. When you have finished your story, scan the Size Limit column for magazines that will accept your story’s word length. Next check the Submission Dates column to make sure the magazine’s time window is open for reading your story (Your story will not be read if you ignore their time window). Finally, tap the word “Guidelines” in the Web site column for complete submission details. These details can be very skimpy or several pages long. Caution: Editors are looking for any excuse to reduce their reading load, so follow all instructions to the letter.

Submission Guidelines is for authors of Short Stories; however many literary magazines also accept poems, essays, and reviews. Not included in the list are specialty magazines. For example, you won’t find magazines of poems only, or magazines that only read a specific genre (science fiction, pornographic, etc.), or magazines that only accept stories from certain authors (women, high school students, residents of Kankakee, etc.).

After reading over 300 Submission Guidelines, certain conclusions were obvious to me.

·        Authors who ignore guidelines are not likely to be accepted.
·       
Competition is tough. Only 1 to 2% of the stories received are ever printed.
·       
It is not uncommon for authors to submit their stories to 20 magazines before being accepted.
·       
Simultaneous submissions are usually permitted if you tell the editor in a cover letter that your story is being sent to other magazines—and promise to inform them if your story is accepted elsewhere. Most editors recognize how hard it is for an author to wait to hear from one magazine before they resubmit their story to another magazine. Typical response time from each magazine may be six months. Do the arithmetic, six months times twenty submissions, or 10 years for each story. I’m a patient guy, but I’m also 80 years old. Have a heart. Not allowing simultaneous submissions should be against the law (my opinion).
·       
Many editors strongly suggest that you read one of their issues before submitting a story. Of course this will help you find the best magazine for your story, but it is simply not practical. Sample copies of their magazine vary from $5.00 to $17.00. Assuming you send your story to twenty magazines, you could spend several hundred dollars and seriously delay ever seeing your story in print. A few magazines have several of their typical stories on their Web sites; more magazines should follow this practice. They might miss selling a few sample copies to authors, but it could also cut down on their reading load since authors would know whether their story is a good fit before submitting it. 
·       
Many editors let you submit your story by email. I expect this method of submitting stories will become more widespread in the future. Submitting by email is quick, reduces response time, and saves the author printing and mailing expenses. 
·       
A Short Story author must write for pleasure, because precious few magazines pay any money. You’re fortunate if you get one or two copies of the magazine when it is issued. Many editors commented that they would like to pay authors, but their budgets are too tight. 
·       
New magazines replace dying magazines at a fairly high rate.

Writing Short Stories may be the very best way to hone your skills before starting the Great American Novel. Short stories aren’t likely to pay your rent—or in many cases even earn you the price of a cup of coffee—but few endeavors bring more pleasure. And nothing, absolutely nothing, beats seeing your story in a print.

REPRINT
Brown, Bob: Who Will Publish My Short Story? Writers’ Journal; Nov/Dec 2007, Page 23.

Return to Guidelines